Fair Trade Services

Release Date: April 26th 2024

Reviewed by: Joshua Andre

The Afters– What God Is Gonna Do (Single) (Amazon mp3/iTunes)

Track Listing:

1. What God Is Gonna Do

Founded by Josh Havens and Matt Fuqua, pop/rock and CCM band The Afters, originating from Dallas, Texas; have had a pretty remarkable and unbelievable ride over the past few years. On the heels of their highly successful, critically acclaimed and widely popular 2013 album Life Is Beautiful featuring smash hits like “Every Good Thing”, “Broken Hallelujah”, the title track and “What We’re Here For”; the band more than took their time with the 3 and a half year wait until their next offering Live On Forever. One would say that the hiatus was excruciating, yet for the band, it seems like the hiatus was just what they needed- with plenty of melodies on this 10-track album designed to inspire and motivate, encouraging believers and non-believers alike to keep fighting the good fight, and keep going on, because God has our back. Reinvigorated with a renewed sense of passion and purpose, there seemed to be no limit at where The Afters will skyrocket too, after what I believe was the release of their career defining album, at least lyrically and thematically. The group also released Fear No More in 2019, and after probably their most CCM album to date, as well as a so-so live album that didn’t inspire me that much; these guys were back with a slew of standalone singles. In January 2022, the group unveiled “Say Goodbye (Say Hello)” (and I have a lot of thoughts about this song!), and in October 2022, The Afters released “This Is Our Moment” Like the previous song which I heavily criticised… boy, can I say that this song needs much more criticism? I reviewed the song here, but let me quote for those who want to read an excerpt…

I’m a big fan of The Afters. Songs like “Light Up The Sky”, “Live On Forever”, “Beautiful Love”, “Ocean Wide”, “Never Going Back To OK”, “Broken Hallelujah”, “Lift Me Up”, “Sunrise”, “Runaway”, “Moments Like This”, “This Life”, “Life Is Beautiful”, “Well Done”, “Fear No More”, “Battles”, “Wake Up My Heart” and “Eyes Of A Believer” are all resonating and impacting. Which makes this latest track, like “Say Goodbye (Say Hello)”, all the more strange and weird. I previously stated that “Say Goodbye (Say Hello)” is a pop song, and apart from the references to God and ‘the enemy’, there’s hardly anything in here musically and lyrically, as well as creatively, that is redeeming. Can I also say that “This Is Our Moment”- another pop song (but this time with an arena/stadium feel/atmosphere!), makes “Say Goodbye” seem like a winner? That’s not saying much for both songs… but I would like to say sorry guys. Both songs do not appeal to me at all- and “This Is Our Moment” doesn’t even sound like something that can be distinctively called ‘CCM’!

I know, I know. CCM shouldn’t even be a genre of music. Maybe The Afters are trying to go into the mainstream. Maybe this song is for a soundtrack of a movie. Maybe it was… I don’t know. Regardless, The Afters have delivered a powerful mainstream song. But bands like Imagine Dragons, OneRepublic, U2, Coldplay, even artists like Ed Sheeran or Robbie Williams- if they can record the song and the melody sound like it fits… well, is this worrying? Shouldn’t Christians be set apart in what they sing about. I know, I know, CCM music is meant to cater to the soccer mums and the stay-at-home parents, and as such it’s family-friendly and mostly doesn’t address the messy parts of faith (or any part of faith where you dive deeper into Jesus- because that’s ‘worship’ music!)… and thus, everything is wrapped up in a bow because American Christians want their CCM songs homogenised and sanitised and separate from the world. However, The Afters seem to, on this song especially, throw together a bunch of cliché lines and expect them to stick. At least with the rest of the songs on their career, there seemed to be effort and genuine trying to inspire people to walk the Christian life, even if it was slightly cliché. On this song, though the band is still well-meaning, I didn’t feel like the song was even trying to speak about Christianity in general. Even if Jesus wasn’t the focus, could this song be speaking about the real issues of life like “Broken Hallelujah”. When Josh Havens sings out ‘…this is what dreams are made of (dreams are made of), I just wanna take it all in right now, this is our, this is our moment, under the bright lights, this is our, this is our moment, our once in a lifetime, making history together, we’ll remember this forever, this is our, this is our moment, and we’ve been waiting our whole lives (whoa), we’ve been waiting our whole lives…we’re just getting started, just getting started, and the world is ours, we’re just getting started, just getting started, and it feels so right…’; I have to groan and call the track generic and cringy. What is the song actually about? This is our moment for what? To share the gospel hopefully. If there was this distinction there… about loving people where they’re at and about spreading the gospel to everyone they meet; then maybe there could be some redeeming quality to the song. As it stands, there’s nothing there. This is a nothing song. Perhaps the group wanted the melody to be like Matthew West’s “Do Something”, sort of like, let’s seize the day and live each moment like our last. If so, then great. But it’s not executed well at all, and I’m inclined to think that this is another ‘generic’ pop song that anyone could sing, that speaks about ‘throwing your hands up in the air’- a track where people take their mobile phones out at concerts and hold them up high for… what reason again? Just because they have a feeling at a concert that gives them a high? Even “We Are The People” from U2’s Bono and The Edge has more meaning than this!

I’ve just inputted almost the entire review for “This Is Our Moment” in this review. This is context. The next single “God Is With Us” has The Afters seemingly overcorrecting. I previously said that “This Is Our Moment” is vague and is a nothing song. It’s still true. But with the piano ballad “God Is With Us”, it seems incredibly heavy handed, and yes, though the band is still well-intentioned and well-meaning, the execution over here isn’t right either. You can read our equally critical review of “God Is With Us” here. While “Say Goodbye” is at times too sunny, acting like the Christian life will forever be rosy and filled with sunshine and rainbows, and “This Is Our Moment” is their attempt at a Coldplay-meets-U2-meets-One Republic atheistic worship song; The Afters move over to the truth of God being with us, but it’s sung in a way that is incredibly cliché. No one going through hell on earth, like a sickness or a loved one dying or a broken marriage or a crisis of faith or deconstruction, will listen to this song and be uplifted. I know, the reality is that God is with us. But sometimes people want others to do life with them, to cry with them, to just be there, instead of preaching to them. There’s a time and a place for this song. Yes, the words and the lyrics are true. Yes, The Afters are singing about Jesus which is good and awesome and fantastic. Singing about Jesus is better than not singing about Jesus. But it’s such a generic song not tied down to any experience of the band members (not that I know of), that I reckon anyone will find it hard to relate to this song in their time of need. The difference between this song and “Heaven Changes Everything” from Big Daddy Weave which is similar in theme… is that Mike Weaver lived through hell. His brother died recently. So when I review “Let It Begin” by Big Daddy Weave, I’ll give it possibly more grace than most other songs. And so, Mike Weaver he has the right to say that song with passion and for it to sound believable. What is this song “God Is With Us” actually about and actually inspired by? Perhaps it is based on something. Then I might be speaking out of turn. But as it stands, this song isn’t a nothing song like the other two that are overly cheerful. But it’s not a cleverly timed release at all (the song released in August 2023, around the same time as the Maui fires).

Now all of this… is a pre-amble. As now, The Afters have released probably their most inspiring and hopeful song since “Life Is Beautiful”. This is the song they should have led with, not any of the other three- and perhaps this is what they are doing- this song being the lead single of the upcoming album and the other three being standalone singles unattached to an album. “What God Is Gonna Do” is a piano only track and an inspirational song chronicling the big moments in the persona’s child’s life (being born, taking their first steps, driving a car for the first time, dedicating their life to Jesus), and with Josh and the band being grateful and thankful for the little moments; this song has a Rascal Flats “My Wish”-type of feel in the best way possible. Josh and co. proudly proclaim that ‘…I hope you know that you are loved, that I’ll be here no matter what, and there’s nothing that you ever have to prove, I’m just proud of who you are, to watch you grow and see your heart, and when I think of all that lies ahead for you, I can’t wait to see what God is gonna do…’, and as we see ourselves and our kids in this song, and as we beam with pride at how the next generation are on fire for Jesus and how God is using them for His glory; we are inspired to be more active in our children’s lives, and watch God move. Or if we don’t’ have children yet, may we start planting the seeds in maybe a mentee whom we can impart wisdom onto, and watch God work in the ways that only He can.

After a more than 3 year wait between albums, “Say Goodbye (Say Hello)” isn’t a good look. Can I also go further and say that “This Is Our Moment” is an even worse look? And “God Is With Us”, though true, sounds incredibly awkward in the face of people going through hell on Earth at the moment. Thankfully though, with one piano only song lasting 4 minutes, all of the previous three songs are forgotten and the band is forgiven. And thus, I will still follow The Afters and their songs; and I still will anticipate their upcoming album. If you’re a fan of CCM, I hope you give these guys more of a chance and look past these three songs, and into this superb and sublime 4^th melody. Because I do hope that forthcoming songs follow the template of “What God Is Gonna Do” and that subsequent songs don’t follow the pattern of the other three songs. If I want to be inspired by The Afters though, then the trio of albums of Light Up The Sky, Life Is Beautiful and Live On Forever is Josh and co. at their best. And so even if you’re not a fan of the group and this new direction (here’s hoping more of their 2024 songs, continue in the vein of “What God Is Gonna Do”, and also recapture that old spark that makes these guys unique and inspiring!); check out this song and let me know what you think! Is “What God Is Gonna Do” too cliché? Too heavy-handed? Not heavy-handed enough? Let me know. And remember though- one song doesn’t make a bad career, and here’s hoping that The Afters can rebound swiftly in terms of having another superb album. They’re still too good to fade away! But as I’ve heard from this song- anything is possible and there’s still life left for this CCM/pop band!

Score: 5/5

RIYL: Building 429, Sanctus Real, Tenth Avenue North, MercyMe, Audio Adrenaline